How to maximise the value of software IP

min readpublished onupdated on

The Uber lawsuit of 2017 serves as a stark reminder of the importance of software intellectual property rights. In a world where proprietary software often forms the cornerstone of a business, understanding the intricacies of copyright laws, licensing, software deposit, and valuation becomes critical. This article aims to provide a comprehensive look at these areaswhile shedding light on how you can better secure and enhance the value of your digital assets in the commercial sphere.

How to maximise the value of software IP
How to maximise the value of software IP

From the moment of its creation, software is protected by copyright laws. This covers various components of the software including the source code, user interface, documentation, multimedia elements, and even the title. It's essential to remember that this protection is automatic, and it exists as soon as the software is made tangible.

Although automatic, these protections are not invincible. To safeguard your rights and provide firm evidence in case of disputes, it's highly recommended to deposit your software with a trusted third-party or in some jurisdictions (such as the United States), the national copyright office.

The importance of software licensing

Software licensing is a significant extension of copyright protection. A software license controls the distribution of the software and dictates what end-users can and can't do with the software. There are various types of licenses, such as proprietary licenses and open-source licenses, each with their own implications.

It's crucial to understand that certain licenses, like the AGPL license for SaaS software, can pose challenges and restrictions, potentially limiting the commercialization potential of a software product.

How the deposit of software provides evidentiary value

The process of making a source code deposit plays an essential role in fortifying your legal standing. Deposits provide tangible proof of your software's existence at a particular time, crucial in case of copyright disputes.

Moreover, a software deposit acts as a deterrent to potential copyright infringement and can help avoid costly litigation. Organizations like Vaultinum, a recognized technology due diligence provider, can guide you through this process smoothly and efficiently.

The role of a deposit in software valuation

The protection of intellectual property is not just about legal defense—it can also significantly enhance a company's value. A source code deposit provides proof that a company's digital assets are owned by the company, offering reassurance to potential investors.

Regularly depositing digital creations can build a company's reputation and increase its credibility, making it more appealing to investors and stakeholders.

The necessity of an IP audit in software valuation

The valuation of software becomes necessary in various contexts, such as fundraising, acquisition, licensing negotiations, or even litigation. Understanding the full worth of a software product goes beyond merely assessing its functionality or market relevance. A comprehensive perspective includes an evaluation of its intellectual property (IP) value, predominantly undertaken through an IP audit.

An IP audit involves a systematic review of a company's IP assets, including patents, trademarks, and crucially, software copyrights. It helps to identify the underlying value, potential risks, and opportunities associated with the software. This audit is especially important when considering investments in tech companies, as it can reveal hidden treasures or potential pitfalls that could significantly affect the investment decision.

One pivotal component of an IP audit is a code scan. This process involves scanning the software’s source code to identify any instances of copyright infringement, which could potentially lead to costly legal disputes. By thoroughly analyzing the software code, a code scan can detect open source components, third-party code, and potential security vulnerabilities that could devalue the software.

Real-World Implications: The Case of Oracle vs. Google

Understanding the theory behind software copyright, licensing, and valuation is important, but let's look at how these concepts apply in a real-world scenario. The landmark case of Oracle vs. Google offers a valuable perspective. 

In this case, Google used portions of Oracle's Java APIs (Application Programming Interfaces) to develop the Android operating system. Oracle sued Google, claiming that they had infringed upon Oracle's copyright. Google, on the other hand, argued that APIs fell under 'fair use,' a doctrine that allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission from the owner. 

After a lengthy legal battle spanning over a decade, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of Google, deeming its use of the APIs as 'fair use.' This case not only emphasized the significance of understanding and respecting software copyright but also underscored the crucial role of licensing. If Oracle had a different licensing agreement on their APIs, they might have had a stronger legal stance.

Furthermore, the immense value of these pieces of software was highlighted throughout the trial. The court documents reveal that Google acquired Android Inc. for an estimated $50 million in 2005. Fast forward to today, and Android is a significant contributor to Google's market valuation, underlining the immense potential value that can be unlocked from strategic software development and its subsequent protection and proper licensing. 

Such instances underscore the importance of professional services like Vaultinum's in safeguarding one's software IP and maintaining its legal and financial integrity.


In conclusion, safeguarding and valuing software are critical aspects of digital asset management. It's essential to understand and leverage the benefits of copyright protection, software licensing, and software deposits, with expert valuation being the key to unlocking your software's true worth. As a trusted provider in this field, Vaultinum is committed to helping you navigate this landscape effectively.



The opinions, presentations, figures and estimates set forth on the website, including in this blog, are for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. For legal advice you should contact a legal professional in your jurisdiction.

The use of any content on this website, including in this blog, for any commercial purposes, including resale, is prohibited, unless permission is first obtained from Vaultinum. Request for permission should state the purpose and the extent of the reproduction. For non-commercial purposes, all material in this publication may be freely quoted or reprinted, but acknowledgement is required, together with a link to this website.

Marine Yborra CMO Vaultinum
Marine YborraMarine is our Marketing Director. She is a branding and brand activation specialist with international experience in BtoB and BtoC.

Recommended for you